Rowan

ArchMaester_Rowan_Lannister - Squire_Jon_Snow_Stark - RDM

14 posts in this topic

 16:36:16 - Levy_Arethar_Mormont attacked Squire_Jon_Snow_Stark dealing 19 damage 
 16:36:30 - Squire_Jon_Snow_Stark attacked Horse (Militia_Wonsz_Saxony) dealing 5 damage 
 16:37:03 - Squire_Jon_Snow_Stark mounted a Charger 
 16:38:08 - Squire_Jon_Snow_Stark attacked ArchMaester_Rowan_Lannister dealing 133 damage 
 16:38:08 - Squire_Jon_Snow_Stark <img=ico_couchedlance> ArchMaester_Rowan_Lannister 
 16:38:08 - Squire_Jon_Snow_Stark killed a member of a friendly faction! 
 16:38:23 - Squire_Jon_Snow_Stark attacked Ftm_Effie_Saxony dealing 27 damage 
 16:38:25 - Ftm_Effie_Saxony attacked Squire_Jon_Snow_Stark dealing 17 damage 
 16:38:50 - Levy_Joovus_Stark attacked Squire_Jon_Snow_Stark dealing 0 damage 

In my opinion, if you have a minute of no combat, no one hitting you and you hitting no one, and all of the sudden you just kill this player in the field, it provides more evidence that you randomed this individual than you didn't random him.

You also do not engage in combat until 15 seconds later. That's a pretty good distance to be moving on a charger. 

There is more evidence that you are trying to skirt around the Skirmish rule. 

------------------------

16:27:44 - ArchMaester_Rowan_Lannister joined the Kingdom of Saxony. 
15:52:47 - The Kingdom of Saxony are now hostile towards the House Stark.
17:22:57 - The Kingdom of Saxony and the House Stark have made peace.

Were you guys at war? 17:22 is the first time i see peace from the 16:00 war. Not sure If I am overlooking it or it's not showing up in logs. Just cannot find it. You may have been at war. Can anyone confirm if Saxony and Starks were at war during this time? 

Edited by Cappy
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
32 minutes ago, Cappy said:

16:38:08 - Squire_Jon_Snow_Stark killed a member of a friendly faction!

They weren't at war because you can see this message come up. A rookie error, Cappy, but I'll let it slide this time.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, Spudgun said:

They weren't at war because you can see this message come up. A rookie error, Cappy, but I'll let it slide this time.

No, I completely understood that message. That's one of the reasons I was confused. There is no peace before the killing in the Logs. The only peace showing in the Logs was an hour later. Which is strange. 

You simply search the logs of Hostile and Peace and it'll show you the wars and peace. However, it's not in the logs.

I'll forgive your mistake of thinking I made a mistake :D. I was simply looking for clarification on the war status as it couldn't have been right in the logs. The reason I asked. Make as few assumtions as possible, and when you make an assumption try to make it as educated as you can even when you know the answer, so I decided it better to confirm with the players actually there, if they answered, that they were or were not at war. 

Edited by Cappy
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This thread has been open long enough. The evidence leans toward Rowan's account of things, so I will rule in favor of the complainant here.

Rowan, post in the refund section for your refund from Jon's bank account.

Jon_Snow, you will receive a warning against your account. 

You now have two warnings against your account. The next incident will surely lead to a ban. 

 

Edited by Cappy
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites